I finally made Reuben sandwiches. I looked at a million different recipes and did a little tweaking.
I owe the most to this recipe:
zingermans-reuben-sandwich-recipe.
Zingerman's sounds like the most amazing deli but it is in Michigan, so a bit far to go for a sandwich.
http://www.zingermansdeli.com/
Here is my version...
Ingredients for four sandwiches:
1 loaf of rye bread
12 slices of corned beef or pastrami
Russian dressing, recipe follows
sauerkraut
12 slices Swiss cheese
Melted butter or olive oil
Russian Dressing:
4 tablespoons mayonnaise
Hot sauce to taste
2 tablespoons sour cream
2 teaspoons chopped parsley
1 tablespoon minced onion
1 tablespoon minced dill pickle
Fresh lemon juice,good quality creamed horseradish and Worcestershire sauce to taste.
First make the Russian dressing. Some recipes I've seen use thousand island dressing which is both gross and wrong. Basically just mix all the ingredients together and leave to meld, I made mine in the morning and left it all day in the fridge. It was sublime.
The Zingerman's recipe had you bake your whole rye loaf for fifteen minutes to crisp the crust. I wouldn't recommend doing this. I don't know if the rye bread I used wasn't quite right. It was really tasty (it was from Birds, the only place I could find it in Derby on the day I made these sarnies, Jack Rabbit's had sold out and Baked only do rye on a Saturday,) but it was a total bitch to slice after crisping up in this way. The bread went all kind of holey inside and I was lucky to salvage four slices. I don't see the point when you are frying the sandwich in its entirety, which crisps everything up nicely anyway.
Sooo, warm up your oven to around gas mark 4. Pop your pastrami in some foil, sprinkle with water, wrap it tightly and place it in the oven, leave for about 15 minutes.
Slice your rye loaf (I sliced mine lengthways, which is quite greedy).
Plaster a slice of bread with Russian dressing. Top with a layer of hot meat, sauerkraut and a couple of slices of cheese. Top with another slice of bread, also spread with Russian dressing.
Scoff half a sandwich with fries (and leftover Russian dressing to dip them in).
Go to a gig, drink four pints of cider. Come home and eat the rest of the sandwich whilst watching and slagging off Florence and the Machine at Glastonbury. Go to bed.